teddthebucfan

Members
  • Content count

    497
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

teddthebucfan last won the day on January 15 2014

teddthebucfan had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

246 Excellent

About teddthebucfan

  • Rank
    Always watching. Always.
  • Birthday 02/18/1992

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male
  • Location
    The Backwoods of Backwoods

Contact Methods

Recent Profile Visitors

3,984 profile views
  1. Movies, Movies, and Movies

    Someone in this thread, I can't remember who and don't want to look it up, once said that my posts here remind them of college, but without the drinking. I don't really know how to feel about that, but I will say that such a statement is appropriate today because what I have to say about the new version of Birth of a Nation by Nate Parker actually ties into college. I'm actually very conflicted as to how I feel about this film. On one hand, from a filmmaking standpoint, this film is superb, especially from a first time director. The acting is solid, the shot composition is great and very haunting at times, and while the film does keep indulging itself in arty symbolic shots it never becomes distracting from the depictions of the horrors of slave life. The first hour is fantastic in its depiction of the life of the slave preacher Nat Turner and his wife. Where it starts to lose me is that,as a history, it completely fails and disregards every rule that historians are supposed to follow. I studied history in college for five years, and one of the things that my history professor lectured us on constantly and made sure that we understood is the fact that, contrary to what it might seem at first, history is not just the Gradgrindian recitation of facts and the events that happened. As historians, we are story tellers, and as such we are bound by the responsibility to give the narrative arcs, the motivations of the people involved, the reasons why events happened as they did, and most importanly the lessons and themes to be learned, all of which form a central historical thesis, and we are obligated to keep the narrative to this thesis to the best of our ability. With that in mind, we are also bound to the obligation to tell the events as they actually happened, an obligation which, as it turns out upon doing some further research, the film has also neglected to follow. Even if I did not know the true story about the Nat Turner Slave Revolt, and all I knew was that this story was based on a true, historic event, I think I would still call it a bad history. Even, after watching this, I still, for lack of a better way to phrase it, don’t know what Nat Turner’s motivation was for deciding to revolt when he did. According to this movie, a number of atrocities happen to him, including the rape of his wife by a slave master, him being whipped at the post for talking back to a white man, and his ban from preaching for baptizing a white man. Even if all these things did happen to him, if this movie had a historical narrative thesis it most likely would have focused on any of these horrific events more as the reason for him breaking and deciding to revolt, but instead the last event that happens before Nat Turner decides to revolt is, and I might be wrong as to what happened here, the death of his grandmother in her sleep from old age. The movie apparently wants to focus more on the events than the history, as it includes events, such as his grandmother’s death, that are seemingly unrelated to the story of the Slave Revolt that he led, which in all honesty is treated like it is an afterthought. I do suppose that this movie is not a literal history book, and I can think of several great movies that aren't completely historically accurate, but the fact is I don’t think that I would feel so strongly about this if it weren’t for the fact that this movie had a great opportunity to right a grand historical wrong. The popular understanding of the Nat Turner Revolt in the American consciousness was so tarnished and sullied for more than a century because of the 1915 DW Griffith version of Birth of a Nation, and this film had a golden opportunity to correct that wrong by reintroducing the American public to the actual events as they happened. While it is, upon further research, more loyal to the events than its predecessor, for all the terrific film making done by Nate Parker, this movie commits many of the same sins that it does. It focuses too much on the visual and entertainment areas than it does on the actual, historical fact and narrative. While the abandonment of historical fact is troubling, I do not regret seeing this movie. The visuals are stunning, the acting superb, and because it inspired me to do more research on the actual events that happened. I can only hope that that last part is true for other people who see this film. Perhaps someday someone will be able to really give an interesting story that more accurately portrays and explains the actual events of the Nat Turner Slave Revolt, but for now this movie, despite its best intentions to right a wrong, is just as guilty.
  2. 2016 MLB Post Season Thread

  3. Movies, Movies, and Movies

    Oh I agree totally, in fact TMNT2 was one of my favorite movies from this year just because of how much it nailed the idea of a live-action Saturday morning cartoon in that it was fast paced, non sensical, action packed, and didn't waste its time getting all dour just to seem "gritty". As for comic adaptations that divert from their source material? Well we just mentioned Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, and for all we talk these days about how people seem to want make lighter comics darker and more cynical, it's important to remember that the Turtles were really just one of a couple of Dark Age comics that got invented into lighter more comedic work. The Mask and Men in Black started out as darker, more cynical comics just to name a few. They even tried that with Batman in the Schumacher films and it was really those two movies' failure from a box office standpoint that killed that off. As for more mainstream stuff, yeah I have to agree. I can't really think of many comic adaptations that were radically different and were still good. I can think of it for books no doubt, but not comics or toys. Even the burton films made changes to Batman but I still think they nailed the tone of Batman as he was at the time.
  4. Movies, Movies, and Movies

  5. 2016 MLB Post Season Thread

    So not only did whoever did this decide to do an incredibly petty and lame joke, they also managed to completely mess up said joke by not spelling the name correctly.
  6. 2016 NHL Off-Season Thread

    Well, why ask us when Consol can tell you themselves via the backpage of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette?
  7. The DC Comics Movie & Television Thread

    So the Lego Sets for the Upcoming Lego Batman movie got previewed, and some of them are actually pretty neat, but more importantly look at what the Arkham Asylum set reveals: BILLY DEE WILLIAMS IS TWO FACE!
  8. 2016 MLB Post Season Thread

    I need this shirt so bad
  9. 2016 MLB Post Season Thread

  10. 2016 MLB Post Season Thread

    [discovering the hard way that image copying from an ipad doesn't work. screaming]
  11. Movies, Movies, and Movies

    I'd say it's more like Young Adults Book Movies in a nutshell, but whatever.
  12. Movies, Movies, and Movies

    I just got out of a screening of Miss Peregrine and I have to say this may be the most confusing film aimed at children I have ever seen. I need someone else who's seen this movie to, if they can, please explain to me succinctly and clearly how this universe works, what the time travel rules are, who and what is when and where, because me if I can. Before I forget , I agree with what everyone's already said about Deepwater horizon. That was one of the best movies I've seen this year.
  13. NFL 2016: The Regular Season Thread

    If the Steelers lose this game I will bicycle from Pittsburgh to the West Virginia border and back.
  14. Movies, Movies, and Movies

    Presumably, but the fact that nearly half of the official Disney press release is hyping up the accomplishments of the Broadway stage play would lead to hope that this would be an adaptation more in line with the stage play.
  15. Movies, Movies, and Movies

    I saw Sully a while back and while I won't go so far as to say it's "fantastic" I'll say that it's really good, enough that it will probably end up being on my top 10 film list at the end of the year. I think what I liked the most is the way that it emphasized the fact that when you go through an accident, especially like that, the part that is the hardest to get through, when you really have to push your way through it, isn't the accident itself. The hard part is living after that with the thoughts of how it could have gone so terribly, terribly wrong. What I didn't like was the padding with stuff like the lookback at him starting out as a pilot or in the military, I thought that was kind of pointless.