Crabcake47

2017 MLB Postseason Thread

Recommended Posts

insert name    1,466

My predictions:

Wild Card

Yankess over Twins

Rockies over D-Backs

 

ALDS

Astros over Red Sox

Indians over Yankees 

NLDS

Dodgers over Rockies

Cubs over Nationals

 

ALCS

Astros over Indians

NLCS

Cubs over Dodgers

 

World Series

Cubs over Astros

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DiePerske    474

NL

NLWC

Rockies over Dbacks.

NLDS

Dodgers defeat Rockies

 

Nationals Over Cubs

 

NLCS

 

Dodgers over Nats.

 

AL

 

WC

Twins over Yankees.

ALDS

Twins over Red Sox

Astros over Indians 

ALCS

Astros over Twins 

 

WS

 

Dodgers. 

 

 

That , or the Cubs just decide to repeat q d ne annoying.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
McCarthy    6,885
21 hours ago, Kramerica Industries said:

 

My own bias aside, two teams that finished, what, six games worse than their opponent making the playoffs because they won a single isolated game at the end of the season? That would make an absolute mockery of MLB's already heavily-flawed playoff system.

 

Any decency in the playoff system was killed for good by the crappy 2012 Cardinals and the 2014 Giants got a few whacks on the dead horse. Now it's just sad.  

 

Ken Rosenthal had a thing in the Athletic today where he pointed out that in Korea they play a doubleheader, but the higher seeded team only has to win one game to advance. I'd spread the two games out to two days, but I think I like that idea. It would create actual races for the #1 Wildcard spot and would really handcuff the second wildcard, which they should be. Even if they manage to win twice and sneak out of the wildcard round they're starting the LDS with their 3rd best starter, which makes getting the #1 overall seed a bigger deal. And if the higher seed loses two at home I wouldn't feel so bad about the clearly better regular season team going out early.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
OnWis97    2,309
21 hours ago, Kramerica Industries said:

 

My own bias aside, two teams that finished, what, six games worse than their opponent making the playoffs because they won a single isolated game at the end of the season? That would make an absolute mockery of MLB's already heavily-flawed playoff system.

My own bias aside, the Twins winning today would not be the mockery.  If it's a mockery, the mere possibility of it is a mockery.  The mockery is the format.  The Twins, per the format, are in New York to play a game that they'll try to win.  

 

(As I've acknowledged, the Twins made a playoff spot that I don't feel should exist).  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cmm    356
47 minutes ago, McCarthy said:

 

Any decency in the playoff system was killed for good by the crappy 2012 Cardinals and the 2014 Giants got a few whacks on the dead horse. Now it's just sad.  

 

Ken Rosenthal had a thing in the Athletic today where he pointed out that in Korea they play a doubleheader, but the higher seeded team only has to win one game to advance. I'd spread the two games out to two days, but I think I like that idea. It would create actual races for the #1 Wildcard spot and would really handcuff the second wildcard, which they should be. Even if they manage to win twice and sneak out of the wildcard round they're starting the LDS with their 3rd best starter, which makes getting the #1 overall seed a bigger deal. And if the higher seed loses two at home I wouldn't feel so bad about the clearly better regular season team going out early.

Rosenthal is mistaken; they play the two games over two days (game 1 is Wednesday night/Thursday morning at 1 am eastern, game 2 is Thursday night/Friday morning...go NC Dinos!). They have a weird playoff system in Korea. It’s a ten-team league. The 4th and 5th place teams play in the two-game Wild Card series, with the 4th place team hosting both games and needing to win only one. The winner faces the 3rd place team in the best-of-five semi-playoff; the winner faces the 2nd place team in the best-of-five playoff; the winner faces the 1st place team in the best-of-seven Korean Series. Until recently, there were a couple of neutral site games in the Korean Series. So the 1st place team has a bye into the finals, but has to sit around for a long time between the end of the season and the start of their postseason.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, OnWis97 said:

My own bias aside, the Twins winning today would not be the mockery.  If it's a mockery, the mere possibility of it is a mockery.  The mockery is the format.  The Twins, per the format, are in New York to play a game that they'll try to win.  

 

(As I've acknowledged, the Twins made a playoff spot that I don't feel should exist).  

 

100% agree. I don't blame the Twins or the Rockies at all. The blame is entirely on the format.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bucfan56    3,857

I can't remember ever being less interested in the playoffs than I am this year. There isn't a single team I really like, three I dislike, one of which I absolutely can't stand.  

 

Want: Rockies over Twins just for gits and shiggles 

 

What's probably going to happen: Red Sox over Dodgers and I won't watch a single solitary second of that series. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
insert name    1,466
16 minutes ago, Bucfan56 said:

I can't remember ever being less interested in the playoffs than I am this year. There isn't a single team I really like, three I dislike, one of which I absolutely can't stand.  

 

Want: Rockies over Twins just for gits and shiggles 

 

What's probably going to happen: Red Sox over Dodgers and I won't watch a single solitary second of that series. 

Rockies vs Twins is FOX's and MLB's worst nightmare. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bucfan56    3,857

Precisely

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tracy Jordan    89

 

7 hours ago, McCarthy said:

 

Any decency in the playoff system was killed for good by the crappy 2012 Cardinals and the 2014 Giants got a few whacks on the dead horse. Now it's just sad.  

 

Ken Rosenthal had a thing in the Athletic today where he pointed out that in Korea they play a doubleheader, but the higher seeded team only has to win one game to advance. I'd spread the two games out to two days, but I think I like that idea. It would create actual races for the #1 Wildcard spot and would really handcuff the second wildcard, which they should be. Even if they manage to win twice and sneak out of the wildcard round they're starting the LDS with their 3rd best starter, which makes getting the #1 overall seed a bigger deal. And if the higher seed loses two at home I wouldn't feel so bad about the clearly better regular season team going out early.

 

I like the idea of a wild card doubleheader format. Then again, if the better wild card team drops the first game but wins the second one, I can see how that might be unfair for that team to have to burn through their two best starting pitchers before facing the #1 seed in the LDS. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DiePerske    474
8 minutes ago, Tracy Jordan said:

 

 

I like the idea of a wild card doubleheader format. Then again, if the better wild card team drops the first game but wins the second one, I can see how that might be unfair for that team to have to burn through their two best starting pitchers before facing the #1 seed in the LDS. 

so what if it's unfair? Should have won the division and not have to worry about it.

 

you know, this sentence alone makes me want to see this happen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
OnWis97    2,309

Looks like a battle of the bullpens.  Good luck vs Cleveland, Yankees.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RyanMcD29    322

FWIW my picks even though we're one hour and two innings into the AL Wild Card game

DLPzYdYX0AEnlUA.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
tp49    317

This game is moving at the speed of glacial.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, insert name said:

Whoever wins, the Indians are gonna have fun with them. 

 

Fun fact - the only team with a better run differential than the Yankees this season was Cleveland.

 

So the Indians are favored and they should be but, theoretically, the Yankees will pose a much bigger threat than the Twins would have.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FGM13    705
3 minutes ago, Kramerica Industries said:

 

Fun fact - the only team with a better run differential than the Yankees this season was Cleveland.

 

So the Indians are favored and they should be but, theoretically, the Yankees will pose a much bigger threat than the Twins would have.

 

Their terrifying bullpen also sets them up perfectly for the playoffs. Don’t sleep on the Yankees, they’re scary.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now