rsaline

Creamer Concept World Cup 2018 - FINALS VOTING

Recommended Posts

Well done all around!  Thanks again to @rsaline for putting this on, and may the best concept win!

Group A

(my group)

 

Group B

Morocco

Spain

Iran

Portugal

 

Group C
Australia

Denmark

France

Honduras

 

Group D

Argentina

Iceland

Nigeria

Croatia

 

Group E

Serbia

Switzerland

Brazil

Costa Rica

 

Group F

Sweden

Mexico

Germany

South Korea

 

Group G

Panama

England

USA

Tunisia

 

Group H

Japan

Colombia

Poland
Senegal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A:

Russia

Egypt

Saudi Arabia

Uruguay

 

Group B:

Spain

Morocco

Portugal

Iran

 

Group C :

Australia

France

Denmark

Honduras

 

Group D :

Argentina

Nigeria

Iceland

Croatia

 

Group E:

Serbia

Costa Rica

Switzerland

Brazil

 

Group F:

Mexico

Sweden

South Korea

Germany

 

Group G:

Panama

England

United States

Tunisia

 

Group H:

Colombia

Senegal

Japan

Poland

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A:

Russia.

Saudi Arabia.

Uruguay.

Egypt.

 

Group B:

Spain.

Morocco.

Iran.

Portugal.

 

Group C :

Australia.

France.

Honduras.

Denmark.

 

Group D :

Argentina.

Croatia.

Iceland.

Nigeria.

 

Group E:

Costa Rica.

Switzerland.

Brazil.

Russia.

 

Group F:

Mexico.

Germany.

South Korea.

Sweden.

 

Group G:

Panama.

England.

Tunisia.

United States.

 

Group H:

Japan.

Senegal.

Poland.

Columbia.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A:

Saudia Arabia

Egypt

Russia

Uruguay

 

Group B:

Portugal

Morocco

Spain

Iran

 

Group C :

France

Denmark

Honduras 

Australia 

 

Group D :

Argentina

Iceland

Croatia

Nigeria

 

Group E:

Serbia

Switzerland

Costa Rica 

Brasil

 

Group F:

Germany

Mexico

Sweden

South Korea

 

Group G:

Panama

England

United States

Tunisia

 

Group H:

Poland

Colombia

Senegal

Japan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A

  • own group

 

Group B

  1. Morocco
  2. Spain
  3. Iran
  4. Portugal

Group C

  1. France
  2. Australia
  3. Danmark
  4. Honduras

Group D

  1. Argentina
  2. Nigeria
  3. Croatia
  4. Iceland

Group E

  1. Serbia
  2. Switzerland
  3. Costa Rica
  4. Brazil

Group F

  1. Mexico
  2. Sweden
  3. South Korea
  4. Germany

Group G

  1. England
  2. Panama
  3. Tunisia
  4. USA

Group H

  1. Senegal
  2. Poland
  3. Colombia
  4. Japan

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First of all, thanks to @rsaline for organizing this amazing competition. Good luck everybody!

GROUP A

1. Egypt
2. Russia

3. Uruguay

4. Saudi Arabia

 

GROUP B

My group

 

GROUP C
1. Australia
2. Denamrk
3. 
France
4. Honduras

GROUP D
1. Argentina
2. Croatia
3.
Nigeria
4. Iceland

GROUP E
1. Serbia
2. Swtitzerland

3. Costa Rica
4. Brazil

GROUP F
1. Mexico
2. Sweden
3.
South Korea
4. Germany

GROUP G
1. Panama
2. England
3.
Tunisia
4. USA

GROUP H
1. Colombia
2. Japan

3. Senegal
4. Poland

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice work everyone!

 

A

Russia

Saudi Arabia

Egypt

Uruguay

 

B

Morocco

Portugal

Spain

Iran

 

France

Australia

Honduras

Denmark

 

D

Argentina

Nigeria

Iceland

Croatia

 

E

Serbia

Costa Rica

Switzerland

Brasil

 

F

Mexico

Sweden

Germany

Korea

 

G

Panama

Tunisia

USA

England

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A- Egypt(my personal favorite), Russia, Saudi Arabia, Uruguay

B- Morocco, Spain, Portugal, Iran

C- Australia, France, Denmark, Honduras

D- Argentina, Iceland, Nigeria, Croatia

E- Switzerland, Costa Rica, Serbia, Brazil

F- Sweden, Mexico, Germany, Korea Republic

G- Panama, Tunisia, England, USA

H- Senegal, Poland, Colombia, Japan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A

  1. Egypt
  2. Russia
  3. Saudi Arabia
  4. Uruguay

 

Group B

  1. Morocco
  2. Spain
  3. Portugal
  4. Iran

 

Group C

  1. Australia
  2. Denmark
  3. Honduras
  4. France

 

Group D

  1. Iceland
  2. Argentina
  3. Nigeria
  4. Croatia

 

Group E

  1. Costa Rica
  2. Serbia
  3. Switzerland
  4. Brazil

 

Group F (Group of Death, IMO)

  1. Mexico
  2. Sweden
  3. Germany
  4. Korea

 

Group G

      Abstained

 

Group H

  1. Colombia
  2. Japan
  3. Poland
  4. Senegal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Amazing work by everybody in the competition! it wasn't easy to rank these concepts, that's for sure.

 

Group A

   My Group

 

Group B

  Morocco

  Spain

  Portugal

  Iran

 

Group C

  Australia

  France

  Honduras

  Denmark

 

Group D

  Argentina

  Nigeria

  Iceland

  Croatia

 

Group E

  Switzerland

  Serbia

  Brazil

  Costa Rica

 

Group F (definitely group of death)

  Sweden

  Mexico

  Germany

  South Korea

 

Group G

  England

  Panama

  United States

  Tunisia

 

Group H

  Senegal

  Colombia

  Poland

  Japan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A

 Saudi Arabia

 Egypt

 Russia

 Uruguay

 

Group B

 Spain

 Iran

 Morocco

 Portugal

 

Group C

 Australia

 France

 Denmark

 Honduras

 

 Group D

  Iceland

  Nigeria

  Argentina  

  Croatia

 

Group E 

  Serbia

  Costa Rica

  Brazil

  Switzerland

 

Group F (My Group of Death)

 Mexico

 Korea

 Germany

 Sweden

 

 Group G

 Engald 

 Tunisia

 Panama

 United States

 

Group H

 Senegal

 Japan

 Poland

 Columbia

 

Great work to everyone! Not one bad concept! 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great batch of concepts everyone!

Group A

1st- Egypt

2nd- Saudi’s Arabia

3rd- Russia

4th- Uruguay

 

Group B

1st- Spain

2nd- Morocco

3rd- Portugal

4th- Iran

 

Group C

1st- Australia

2nd- France

3rd- Honduras

4th- Denmark

 

Group D

1st- Argentina

2nd- Nigeria

3rd- Honduras

4th- Denmark

 

Group E

1st- Switzerland

2nd- Serbia

3rd- Costa Rica

4th- Brazil

 

Group F

1st- Sweden

2nd- Mexico

3rd- South Korea

4th- Germany

 

Group G

1st-Panama

2nd- Tunisia

3rd- England

4th- USA

 

Group H

1st- Japan

2nd- Senegal

3rd- Colombia

4th- Poland

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A

  1. Saudi Arabia
  2. Egypt
  3. Russia
  4. Uruguay

Group B

  1. Morocco
  2. Portugal
  3. Spain
  4. Iran

Group C

  1. Australia
  2. Honduras
  3. France
  4. Denmark

Group D

  1. Nigeria
  2. Iceland
  3. Argentina
  4. Croatia

Group E

  1. Costa Rica
  2. Serbia
  3. Switzerland
  4. Brazil

Group F

  1. Mexico
  2. Korea
  3. Sweden
  4. Germany

Group G

  1. Panama
  2. England
  3. Tunisia
  4. United States

Group H

  1. Senegal
  2. Poland
  3. Japan
  4. Colombia

 

Some of these were designs I really liked but I felt they were too close to the originals, which to me felt like it went against the spirit of the competition. Wish I would've participated these are a lot of fun to look at!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A

1. Russia
2. Egypt
3. Uruguay
4. Saudi

 

Group B

1. Spain
2. Morroco
3. Portugal
4. Iran

 

Group C

1. France
2. Aussie
3. Denmark
4. Honduras

 

Group D

1. Argentina
2. Iceland
3. Nigeria 
4. Croatia

 

Group E 

1. Costa Rica
2. Serbia
3. Swiss
4. Brazil

 

Group F 

1. Germany
2. Sweden
3. Mexico
4. South Korea

 

Group G

1. Tunisia
2. Panama
3. England
4. United States

 

Group H

1. Colombia
2. Japan
3. Senegal
4. Poland

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A

Egypt

Russia

Uruguay

Saudi Arabia

 

Group B

Morocco

Iran

Portugal

Spain

 

Group C

Hondarus

Denmark

France

Australia 

 

Group D

My Group

 

Group E

Costa Rica

Brazil

Serbia

Switzerland

 

Group F

South Korea

Mexico

Sweden

Germany

 

Group G

Panama

England

Tunisia

United States

 

Group H

Senegal

Japan

Poland

Columbia 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

GROUP A

Saudi Arabia

Egypt

Russia

Uruguay

 

GROUP B

Morocco

Spain

Portugal

Iran

 

GROUP C

Australia

France

Honduras

Denmark

 

GROUP D

Argentina

Croatia

Iceland

Nigeria

 

GROUP E

Serbia

Switzerland

Costa Rica

Brazil

 

GROUP F (My group, also the hardest. Good work to everybody in this one!)

Germany

Mexico

Korea

Sweden

 

GROUP G

England

Panama

Tunisia

USA

 

Group H

Senegal

Poland

Colombia

Japan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Group A

  1. Saudi Arabia
  2. Russia
  3. Egypt
  4. Uruguay

 

Everyone in this group did so well! I'm giving first place to Der Kaiser & Saudi Arabia because that's a difficult country to work with and they absolutely pulled it off! Great presentation as well! The decision for second place was do tough that I went back and forth on for a while. I thought Egypt had the better crest, but Russia executed the thought behind the crest better. In the end, I went with Russia because of the little touches like the Cyrillic-inspired font/numbers and the more unique kits (the Egyptian clash set reminded me too much of a Germany kit). It should be noted that Uruguay did a very admirable job for a hand-drawn concept.

 

Group B

  1. Morocco
  2. Spain
  3. Portugal
  4. Iran

Morocco ran away with this group for me... Everything about it is so well thought out with such fine touches! I love the shade of green on the clash kit. Excellent work, raysox. 

 

Second place was another close battle... every concept did at least one thing well. I really like the home Portuguese kit, I like all the detail in the Spanish crest, and I love the concept behind the Iranian branding. Ultimately, I picked Spain because I think it was the most complete concept across crest, kit, and execution. 

 

Group C

  1. Honduras
  2. Australia
  3. France
  4. Denmark 

This may have been the toughest group for me to judge. Nothing really jumped out at me if I'm being blunt... I think I had all four concepts in first place at one time or another. Ultimately, I decided that Honduras won the group for me because it's really hard to do a Honduras concept. There's nothing memorable about their current or past looks, and I think PackerFan98 made a nice crest and brought in some elements like the gold color to turn it into something memorable.

 

I think the Chelsea-borrowed Nike kit turned me off to the French design and the Denmark design just didn't take enough risks for me, which left Australia in second place. To be honest, I think the execution of the Aussie concept is REALLY good (those numbers are phenomenal), but I disagree with brand direction and I think it tried to do too much between the Commonwealth star, sand dune patterns, aboriginal textures, flags, kangaroos, weird colors/patterns on the (IMO, very ugly) clash kit.  In my mind, it's better to do one idea super well than to do ten ideas just ok. Still, on the strength of the craftsmanship of the concept, I have the Socceroos going through to the next round.

 

Group D

  1. Argentina
  2. Iceland
  3. Croatia
  4. Nigeria

I don't have much to say about this group... I think the top two teams are pretty evident and ultimately, maybe not enough chances were taken by the competitors in this group.

 

Group E

  1. Serbia
  2. Switzerland
  3. Costa Rica
  4. Brazil

Hats-off to Serbia and BlackBolt for an amazing concept from idea through execution. Unlike Australia, it narrowed its best ideas down to 2-3 ideas and then just hit those notes perfectly. Well done! It may be my favorite out of them all.

 

The second place decision again came down to the wire, but the finer touches on the Swiss kit put it ahead in the end. But another tip of the cap to VikingsAiden who did a really great job with a hand-drawn concept and almost advanced for me. 

 

Group F

  1. Mexico
  2. Germany
  3. Sweden
  4. South Korea

WHAT. A. GROUP.  

 

giphy.gif

 

Unfortunate for all the competitors that you ended up in the group of death, as I probably would have advanced you all should you have been placed in other groups. But a well-deserved round of applause for you all!

 

That's the best El Tri concept I've ever seen and, again, it takes only its strongest ideas and it smashes them into the back of the net like a Yeboah volley. A standing ovation for you, gswansea!

 

I love the touches of red and the crest of the Sweden concept, but the Germany concept by Zeus hits me in a 90s Vancouver Canucks way and I cannot deny that it appeals to me. Even the presentation of the concept leans into the black/red/yellow motif and it's enough to put it over the top for me. 

 

Group G

  1. Panama
  2. England
  3. Tunisia
  4. USA

Panama takes this group EASILY on the quality of the crest alone. Job well done Lafarge!

 

The rest of this group is a nightmare. The USA concept is perhaps the gaudiest thing I've ever seen, but it gets docked real points by unintentionally converting it's patriotic home kit into a big Rising Sun flag.... yikes.

 

The Tunisia concept features a much better crest than the actual Tunisian emblem; however, the decision to turn to a fluorescent-pink PRIMARY kit feels like an intentional decision to riff off the uber-popular Nike Nigerian kits, but without any actual rhyme or reason as to why. That doesn't fly with me, Eagles of Carthage.

 

Which brings us to England and the three one lion. The logo is far too "American Sports" to be accepted over there and the design misses out on the importance of three lions, but the execution is good and DawgPac showed enough restraint on the kits to make a striking design. It's bold, impractical, and different... but that's enough for me to move it on. 

 

Group H

  1. Colombia
  2. Japan
  3. Senegal
  4. Poland

Columbia takes this group for me on the simplicity and cleanliness of the concept. The crest is simple and brilliantly Colombian, and the kits have just enough detail to not be boring. 

 

Like the real World Cup, Senegal and Japan basically tie to move on. They both did a very good job of taking their national mascots (the lion and the three-legged raven) and local patterns/textures and incorporating them into manufacturer templates. Ultimately, I decided on Japan because the crest did a better job of tying-in the national flag and giving the three-legged crow a geometric solution. 

 

 

A JOB WELL DONE TO ALL THE CONTESTANTS AND GOOD LUCK IN THE ROUNDS TO COME

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

GROUP A:

1. Saudi Arabia 

2. Egypt (close 1/2, both well done)

3. Uruguay

4. Russia

GROUP B:

1. Morocco (clear class of the group)

2. Spain

3. Portugal

4. Iran

GROUP C:

1. Australia (I appreciate the risk taken)

2. Honduras

3. Denmark

4. France

GROUP D:

1. Argentina

2. Iceland

3. Croatia

4. Nigeria

GROUP F:

1. Mexico (I dropped my jaw when I saw this, well done)

2. Sweden 

3. Germany

4. South Korea

GROUP G:

1. Panama (LOVE the crest)

2. England

3. Tunisia

4. USA

GROUP H:

1. Senegal

2. Colombia

3. Japan

4. Poland

 

I may post some more in depth analysis once it’s all done, but I hope everyone takes away something from this, I know I did back in 2014.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, mamiller99 said:

Great batch of concepts everyone!

Group A

1st- Egypt

2nd- Saudi’s Arabia

3rd- Russia

4th- Uruguay

 

Group B

1st- Spain

2nd- Morocco

3rd- Portugal

4th- Iran

 

Group C

1st- Australia

2nd- France

3rd- Honduras

4th- Denmark

 

Group D

1st- Argentina

2nd- Nigeria

3rd- Honduras

4th- Denmark

 

Group E

1st- Switzerland

2nd- Serbia

3rd- Costa Rica

4th- Brazil

 

Group F

1st- Sweden

2nd- Mexico

3rd- South Korea

4th- Germany

 

Group G

1st-Panama

2nd- Tunisia

3rd- England

4th- USA

 

Group H

1st- Japan

2nd- Senegal

3rd- Colombia

4th- Poland

Your Group D vote needs to be fixed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Group A

1. Russia
2. Egypt
3. Uruguay
4. Saudi

 

Group B

(My Group)

 

Group C

1. France
2. Aussie
3. Denmark
4. Honduras

 

Group D

1. Argentina
2. Iceland
3. Nigeria 
4. Croatia

 

Group E 

1. Costa Rica
2. Serbia
3. Swiss
4. Brazil

 

Group F 

1. Germany
2. Sweden
3. Mexico
4. South Korea

 

Group G

1. England
2. Panama
3. Tunisia
4. United States

 

Group H

1. Colombia
2. Japan
3. Senegal
4. Poland

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now