Jump to content


Photo

Just saw this over on Puck Drawn


  • Please log in to reply
13 replies to this topic

Poll: Potential plagiarism

Do you think he plagiarized?

You cannot see the results of the poll until you have voted. Please login and cast your vote to see the results of this poll.
Vote Guests cannot vote

#1 WNDUP FX

WNDUP FX
  • Member

  • Members
  • 221 posts
  • Joined: Jun 6/10


Posted March 28, 2012 - 12:00

I know Fraser is pretty revered around these parts, but after reading the post and looking at both logos the poster Calvin has some pretty good points.

Do you think there's enough changed to the second logo to set it apart from the original Tiger Cats logo?

Fraser's Columbus Black Bears logo:
Posted Image

Hamilton Tiger Cats Alternate logo:
Posted Image

The comments on Puck Drawn are here for anyone wishing to follow the discussion:
http://www.puckdrawn...4.html#comments

Edit: Moderators, this probably should've gone in the concept section, feel free to move it.

#2 texfischer

texfischer
  • Member

  • Members
  • 225 posts
  • Joined: Mar 30/11
    • Location:Youngstown, Ohio

    • Favourite Logos:'67 Penguins, Steelers, Pirates "P", '27 Maple Leafs, LA Chargers, OSU, Brutus Buckeye,

Posted March 28, 2012 - 12:08

I think it's changed enough, I'm just wondering why the guy is wearing gloves while hoisting the cup...

#3 mania

mania
  • Member

  • Members
  • 7,451 posts
  • Joined: Sep 26/06
    • Location:Minneapolis, MN


Posted March 28, 2012 - 12:10

It's the same perspective of a growling/snarling animal, but I don't see anything else that's really close.

Eyes, mouth, nose, teeth, tongue... nothing is alike.

As well, you can tell that Fraser's is mirrored... while the T-Cats isn't.

#4 pcgd

pcgd
  • Member

  • Members
  • 7,278 posts
  • Joined: May 17/04
    • Location:Nap Town


Posted March 28, 2012 - 12:23

Hell no. Had I done a front facing bear, panther or tiger it would have come out looking similar too. Hell I've done it. I did a bulldog logo for a high school, and it ended up looking very similar to an alternate Georgia logo. I had never seen the logo before but they ended up similar enough even in line weight and everything.

And actually few if any of Calvin's points are valid. He says the tongue shape, both are different. He says the teeth, both are different. The interior lines are somewhat similar but that could be easily a coincidence and same with the overall shape.

Not everything is plagiarism folks. Sometimes coincidences do happen.

Plus the biggest thing: Why? He's done hundreds of logos so far without a hint of plagiarism and then he's going to do it for a online contest?

#5 drdougfresh

drdougfresh
  • Hopelessly Optimistic Detroit Fan

  • Members
  • 3,952 posts
  • Joined: Jun 5/11
    • Location:PHX, AZ


Posted March 28, 2012 - 13:21

Wow. I am actually sad that there are 2 'yes' votes. Like pcgd said, it happens sometimes. johnny's post with all the links kind of proves this point.

Perfect example: BrandMooreArt posted this the other day, and it's also similar:

Posted Image

Can't wait to hear FD's response to this.

icons-social-04_zps7c6adeed.png . icons-social-02_zps37962ec7.png . icons-social-03_zps8a3ff835.png


team-banner_zps27a8bafa.png


#6 mattwillcox

mattwillcox
  • Member

  • Members
  • 252 posts
  • Joined: Oct 18/11
    • Location:Ontario, Canada


Posted March 28, 2012 - 13:26

Fraser's logo (as well as the Ticats) is of an extremely popular perspective done in an extremely popular style, they're bound to look somewhat similar. That's where the similarities end though. As pcgd said Calvin's points aren't valid at all, and really all I think Calvin did was make an ass out of himself.

#7 gordie_delini

gordie_delini
  • Member

  • Members
  • 3,557 posts
  • Joined: Sep 1/04


Posted March 28, 2012 - 13:27

guaranteed it's a coincidence. FD has his stuff ripped off all the time, so he knows how it feels to have his work jacked. He's too good and has too much professionalism to pull a stunt like that. Period.
Posted Image

#8 CS85

CS85
  • 19 spooky 47 me

  • Members
  • 13,233 posts
  • Joined: Sep 14/05
    • Location:Champaign, IL


Posted March 28, 2012 - 13:27

Generic logos are generic. Basic shadowing on a typical perspective tends to all look the same if it involves fur. Chances are excellent that the Black Bears designer used an FD tutorial to make that logo anyway.

#9 The Fixer

The Fixer
  • Member

  • Members
  • 1,301 posts
  • Joined: Aug 26/09
    • Location:Minneapolis


Posted March 28, 2012 - 13:47

I tried to do a wildcat logo and it came out jsut like the tiger cats. That whole layout of the logo is just very natural and easy to come up with. if you sit down with a front view of a snarling animal, odds are your lines are going to come out like that. It is just natural from that perspective.

#10 BigBubba

BigBubba
  • Member

  • Members
  • 4,351 posts
  • Joined: Jul 16/11
    • Location:in phone

    • Favourite Logos:Ball in Glove, Whalers, North Stars, Robo-Pen

Posted March 28, 2012 - 14:24

There are only so many ways to draw a front-facing angry bear/tiger.

Sigggggggggggggggggggggg_zpsc24d13ab.png

PotD: 29/1/12


#11 Fox

Fox
  • Believe in Boston

  • Members
  • 1,459 posts
  • Joined: Mar 14/11
    • Location:Connecticut


Posted March 28, 2012 - 18:27

Possibly inspiration, but no, does not look like plagiarism to me.

All of that aside, really rice logo and concept.

fenwaybanner.jpg
 


#12 sparky chewbarky

sparky chewbarky
  • Member

  • Members
  • 1,200 posts
  • Joined: Apr 9/09
    • Location:sparkychewbarky@live.com


Posted March 28, 2012 - 18:41

I'm just wondering why the guy is wearing gloves while hoisting the cup...


...or how he got his pants over those shin guards!!

A funny story...
When I was a young whipper-snapper, I'd laugh at the "old fools" puttin' on their shin pads and skates first, and THEN pulling on their hockey pants.
They'd have to slit the pant legs to be able to get them over their skates.
I would just laugh to myself and shake my head as I geared up.

Now that I'm an "old fool", I do the same thing:
I put on my skates and shin guards first and then pull my slitted pants over them.
When you've got a bit of a gut, and you've got your hockey pants on...
You can't reach your skates to do them up!!
Ha-ha.

#13 andrewharrington

andrewharrington
  • The Go-Getter

  • Members
  • 5,474 posts
  • Joined: Aug 10/04
    • Location:Cleveland, OH > Indianapolis, IN


Posted March 28, 2012 - 19:01

Lord knows I'm not the biggest FD fan, but not everything that's similar is plagiarism.
I still don't have a website, but I have a dribbble now! http://dribbble.com/andyharry

[The postings on this site are my own and do not necessarily represent the position, strategy or opinions of the adidas Group and its brands.]

#14 SDX

SDX
  • Member

  • Members
  • 696 posts
  • Joined: Apr 22/06
    • Location:Manchester, England


Posted March 29, 2012 - 03:36

Lord knows I'm not the biggest FD fan, but not everything that's similar is plagiarism.



This sums the thread up perfectly. Sports logos have a unique look and this type of shading is more and more popular.
there are only so many ways you can draw a growling bear, cat, etc etc.

As designers and even humans we are influenced by things we see and hear and they reflect on our work, even if we don't realise it at the time.

All designs in this thread are unique but draw on similar styles.
Posted ImagePosted ImagePosted ImagePosted Image