Need some opinions on this logo I'm working on

[AthayaDZN]

I'm working on this personal branding for a client, which one do you guys prefer? the difference is on the hilt of the sword.

I'm personally leaning more towards the Sharp one but I wanted to hear other opinions,
Thanks 
_____________________________________________________________

[stumpygremlin]

From what I can tell, the only difference between "Mid" and "Edge" is that the point of the shield on "Edge" goes up a bit higher? Correct me if I'm wrong.

 

But, I'm leaning towards "Mid." The angles on the hilt of "Sharp" don't jibe with the rest of the logo, at least to my eye.

[AthayaDZN]

22 hours ago, stumpygremlin said:

From what I can tell, the only difference between "Mid" and "Edge" is that the point of the shield on "Edge" goes up a bit higher? Correct me if I'm wrong.

 

But, I'm leaning towards "Mid." The angles on the hilt of "Sharp" don't jibe with the rest of the logo, at least to my eye.

Yessir that's where the difference is.

Thanks for letting me know your opinion, mid is definitely the safest option as it's a combination of both Sharp and Edge.

[stumpygremlin]

1 hour ago, AthayaDZN said:

Yessir that's where the difference is.

Thanks for letting me know your opinion, mid is definitely the safest option as it's a combination of both Sharp and Edge.

Honestly, the difference between "Mid" and "Edge" is negligible. Most people wouldn't notice the difference, and hell, I had to look really closely to notice.

[sinistas]

I like "Edge" the best. The border doesn't overwhelm as much compared to the others.

I know it's not what you asked for, but the blade and hilt not lining up is really bugging me.