Brass

*NHA REDESIGN ROUND I VOTING!*

Recommended Posts

Arizona

Austin

Portland

San Diego

LA

Honolulu

KC

Detroit

Chicago

Toronto

Atlanta

Hartford

Pittsburgh

Ottawa

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Per the original contest thread:

- You will design a home uniform, away uniform and main logo for your team.

Seems pretty clear.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Per the original contest thread:

- You will design a home uniform, away uniform and main logo for your team.

Seems pretty clear.

if you say so.

the organizer, who i'm sure has looked over all of the entries and has probably been checking in here from time to time, hasn't said anything as of yet. until brass says something, all you people are doing is complaining.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To me recoloring is enough as far as designing a logo.

I can create jerseys with photoshop but don't ask me to create logos because I can't draw for jack-sqwat (spelling ? :P) and I feel like that's what might have happened with some of the so called copy cat artists...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Why does the Denver Explorer look like Teddy Roosevelt?

I dunno lol. I just pictured Teddy Roosevelt for some reason when I started on it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll accept the logos for now, but let's just put it this way: in the next few rounds, you're not going to be as lucky....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most of these votes are uniform-based ones. A lot of people didn't have the logo and wordmark apart from the jersey, which would have helped. I couldn't even tell what some of them were (Pittsburgh, for example).

1. Boise

2. Seattle

3. Portland

4. St. Louis

5. Los Angeles

6. Honolulu (but I love the Explorers logo)

7. Kansas City

8. Detroit

9. Chicago

10. Buffalo

11. Edmonton

12. Hartford

13. New York

14. Ottawa

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Most of these votes are uniform-based ones. A lot of people didn't have the logo and wordmark apart from the jersey, which would have helped. I couldn't even tell what some of them were (Pittsburgh, for example).

I will say that myself and many others posted both uniforms and logos but all that was posted in this thread were uniforms.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Arizona

Austin

Portland

San Diego

Los Angeles

Honolulu

Montana

Rochester

Chicago

Buffalo

Atlanta

Delaware

New York

South Carolina

disappointed that hardly any of the concepts featured a stand alone logo, even if it was a stolen job.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Arizona

Austin

Dallas

St. Louis

Minnesota

Honolulu (very close)

Kansas City

ABSTAIN

Boston

Buffalo

Edmonton

New York

South Carolina

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
- You have one week to design the package.

Technically brass didn't say that you had to design a logo, but he did say "You have one week to design the package." To me, a package is the entire set. Primary, secondary (if there are any) logos, wordmarks (if there are any), and uniforms. I guess to each person, the term "package" may not have the same meaning, so I don't know if there is a way to address that issue of someone not having an original or completely original logo.

I'm not saying that those who stole any logos should be disqualified, but I think that it is something that should be looked at; however, it would be an issue that could ruin the whole tournament, so perhaps not punishing someone would be best. Some people will not vote for a team in this contest because they stole or borrowed someone else's logo. I don't have a problem with people who will not vote for a concept that does not have an original logo, but I do have a problem with some teams getting essentially a free pass into the second round because their opponent was not completely original. I guess there is no way to around this issue, but it is just my two cents, and I wanted to throw that out there.

I didn't enter because of understanding of the stipulation that you had to do a logo from scratch.

No time (and no ability, really) to get it done.

And I probably would have dominated the rest of the uniform design part of the contest. (or not :) )

But the fact remains, there's plenty of us who would have entered had they been able to use someone else's logo.

And that's not to say I'm bleating about not being able to enter.

You work out pretty quickly that this is a place where copying other people's stuff is a no-no, and it's also tough on those who do design their won logo and end up cometeing against something a pro-designer has done for a minor league team (or similar)

I'm just saying those who did use existing logos and re-coloured shouldn't expect to win the comp, or even the first round as the rules clearly stated designing the whole package.

Had I put my hand up, my Devils package looked like this:

Delaware-Devils.gif

However, let's review.

The logo is from Rival Art

The font is Dark Crystal

The uniform design is a mix of the Ice Pilots body, with full length sleeves and the SunDogs striping, kindly put together by Jesse.

The colours were a mix of the supposed new and old colours of the team.

What have I actually contributed, and/or learnt from the process? Bugger all really.

But fingers crossed I win. Because that would be important.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
- You have one week to design the package.

Technically brass didn't say that you had to design a logo, but he did say "You have one week to design the package." To me, a package is the entire set. Primary, secondary (if there are any) logos, wordmarks (if there are any), and uniforms. I guess to each person, the term "package" may not have the same meaning, so I don't know if there is a way to address that issue of someone not having an original or completely original logo.

I'm not saying that those who stole any logos should be disqualified, but I think that it is something that should be looked at; however, it would be an issue that could ruin the whole tournament, so perhaps not punishing someone would be best. Some people will not vote for a team in this contest because they stole or borrowed someone else's logo. I don't have a problem with people who will not vote for a concept that does not have an original logo, but I do have a problem with some teams getting essentially a free pass into the second round because their opponent was not completely original. I guess there is no way to around this issue, but it is just my two cents, and I wanted to throw that out there.

I didn't enter because of understanding of the stipulation that you had to do a logo from scratch.

No time (and no ability, really) to get it done.

And I probably would have dominated the rest of the uniform design part of the contest. (or not :) )

But the fact remains, there's plenty of us who would have entered had they been able to use someone else's logo.

And that's not to say I'm bleating about not being able to enter.

You work out pretty quickly that this is a place where copying other people's stuff is a no-no, and it's also tough on those who do design their won logo and end up cometeing against something a pro-designer has done for a minor league team (or similar)

I'm just saying those who did use existing logos and re-coloured shouldn't expect to win the comp, or even the first round as the rules clearly stated designing the whole package.

Had I put my hand up, my Devils package looked like this:

Delaware-Devils.gif

However, let's review.

The logo is from Rival Art

The font is Dark Crystal

The uniform design is a mix of the Ice Pilots body, with full length sleeves and the SunDogs striping, kindly put together by Jesse.

The colours were a mix of the supposed new and old colours of the team.

What have I actually contributed, and/or learnt from the process? Bugger all really.

But fingers crossed I win. Because that would be important.

Should have made the jersey # 666. Also the white logo on the white jersey doesn't go very good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.