SI Ranks the NHL's New Third Jerseys

[TurnTwo 0]

Link

[BryanSmalls 101]

The Isles at 15 out of 19? Really?

"Automatic points for keeping the fish sticks guy off of it. Going back to the old colors, again, is nice if only for reminding Islanders fans that this was a dominant, winning team once upon a time."

Whereas teams (Pens #1, Philly #3, Canadiens #4 (so a Centennial celebration jerseys officially counts as thirds?), Blackhawks #5, Oilers, #6, TML #8), in other classic looks are higher?

[EddieJ1984 1,627]

I agree with them for the most part, flyers shouldv'e been #2 (I'd say #1, but everyone loves those pens jerseys so much, and I do agree its good lookin)

also this link.html starts at #19

[McCall 1,359]

Ahh, the Blues getting some love here at #2. Good to see that beauty is apperciated.

[-kj 2,335]

I agree with them for the most part, flyers shouldv'e been #2 (I'd say #1, but everyone loves those pens jerseys so much, and I do agree its good lookin)

also this link.html starts at #19

I'm going to disagree here, as I see the Flyers' thirds as being horrible. Yes, I know they're mimicking what they used to wear, but that doesn't make it actually look good. It's all in the details--mismatched nameplate and numbers spilling out of the striping.

[Brian E 377]

The Isles at 15 out of 19? Really?

"Automatic points for keeping the fish sticks guy off of it. Going back to the old colors, again, is nice if only for reminding Islanders fans that this was a dominant, winning team once upon a time."

Whereas teams (Pens #1, Philly #3, Canadiens #4 (so a Centennial celebration jerseys officially counts as thirds?), Blackhawks #5, Oilers, #6, TML #8), in other classic looks are higher?

totally agree. the isles at 15 is ridiculous. one spot behind the BOLTS jersey?! riiiiight. considering that the oilers almost have an identical design, it's fairly amusing to see them 9 spots higher.

no contest on the pens and blues being 1-2. they're by far and away the best of the bunch.

[infrared41 9,123]

1. Montreal

2. Toronto

3. Pittsburgh

4. Islanders

5. Edmonton

6. St.Louis

7. Buffalo

8. Philadelphia

The rest just plain suck. BOLTS? SENS? Seriously?

[BBM 8]

I guess I liked the Kings jersey a little more than they did.

[chuckymack 97]

1. Montreal

2. Toronto

3. Pittsburgh

4. Islanders

5. Edmonton

6. St.Louis

7. Buffalo

8. Philadelphia

The rest just plain suck. BOLTS? SENS? Seriously?

I agree with you on the top seven, but my list goes a little like this:

1. St. Louis

2. Toronto

3. Montreal

4. Pittsburgh

5. Buffalo

6. Vancouver

7. Islanders

8. Edmonton

...And I also wholeheartedly agree that the shortened nicknames on the front of the jerseys (and wordmarks in general on hockey jerseys) just plain suck.

[OnWis97 4,529]

I agree with them for the most part, flyers shouldv'e been #2 (I'd say #1, but everyone loves those pens jerseys so much, and I do agree its good lookin)

also this link.html starts at #19

I'm going to disagree here, as I see the Flyers' thirds as being horrible. Yes, I know they're mimicking what they used to wear, but that doesn't make it actually look good. It's all in the details--mismatched nameplate and numbers spilling out of the striping.

Thank you.

I'd rather they just go back to the orange jersey relegated to "alt" status a few years ago. Some retro is "tacky-cool". This is just tacky.

[flynnagain 0]

I love the RBK St. Louis third...i feel a strange bond with it.......take a look at the RBK third crest i did for the Sting a year prior to this one

http://www.flynnagain.com/team/hockey/inde...;id=105&t=0

[Island_Style 163]

I like some of these a lot. I can't wait till the Panthers decide to bust one out. I hope they do more to it than just the same design, different color.

[STL FANATIC 145]

The Isles at 15 out of 19? Really?

"Automatic points for keeping the fish sticks guy off of it. Going back to the old colors, again, is nice if only for reminding Islanders fans that this was a dominant, winning team once upon a time."

Whereas teams (Pens #1, Philly #3, Canadiens #4 (so a Centennial celebration jerseys officially counts as thirds?), Blackhawks #5, Oilers, #6, TML #8), in other classic looks are higher?

But most of those vintage looks actually are appealing.

Gauge my eyes out blue with bright orange, huge stripes that aren't consistent throughout the design--I don't see how it deserves top 10 myself.

[BryanSmalls 101]

The Isles at 15 out of 19? Really?

"Automatic points for keeping the fish sticks guy off of it. Going back to the old colors, again, is nice if only for reminding Islanders fans that this was a dominant, winning team once upon a time."

Whereas teams (Pens #1, Philly #3, Canadiens #4 (so a Centennial celebration jerseys officially counts as thirds?), Blackhawks #5, Oilers, #6, TML #8), in other classic looks are higher?

But most of those vintage looks actually are appealing.

Gauge my eyes out blue with bright orange, huge stripes that aren't consistent throughout the design--I don't see how it deserves top 10 myself.

Maybe she didn't like the sock stripes not being completely connect

[ferrousoxide66 2]

I agree with them for the most part, flyers shouldv'e been #2 (I'd say #1, but everyone loves those pens jerseys so much, and I do agree its good lookin)

also this link.html starts at #19

I'm going to disagree here, as I see the Flyers' thirds as being horrible. Yes, I know they're mimicking what they used to wear, but that doesn't make it actually look good. It's all in the details--mismatched nameplate and numbers spilling out of the striping.

Actually, i'm diggin' the white nameplate.

[infrared41 9,123]

1. Montreal

2. Toronto

3. Pittsburgh

4. Islanders

5. Edmonton

6. St.Louis

7. Buffalo

8. Philadelphia

The rest just plain suck. BOLTS? SENS? Seriously?

I agree with you on the top seven, but my list goes a little like this:

1. St. Louis

2. Toronto

3. Montreal

4. Pittsburgh

5. Buffalo

6. Vancouver

7. Islanders

8. Edmonton

...And I also wholeheartedly agree that the shortened nicknames on the front of the jerseys (and wordmarks in general on hockey jerseys) just plain suck.

I should have included Vancouver in my list of the ones I liked. I guess I was just so stunned by how ugly the others were that I missed it.

[jrodsep 567]

Absolutely Beautiful. BOTH of them should be regular jerseys....

[Legend 61]

Throwbacks

[Delux247 37]

1- Carolina

2- Tampa Bay

3- Phoenix

4- San Jose

5- Los Angeles

6- Atlanta

7- St. Louis

8- Ottawa

9- Buffalo

10- Boston

11- Vancouver

12- Toronto

13- Dallas

14- Philadelphia

15- Pittsburgh

16- Chicago

17- New York

18- Edmonton

[raysox 2,484]

15- Pittsburgh

16- Chicago

17- New York

18- Edmonton

don't like classic jerseys, eh?