Patchez Posted September 22, 2009 Author Share Posted September 22, 2009 Look at other NFL logos, they generally don't have...I appreciate the C+C from you all!I'm not saying you have to copy an existing logo, but with how many elements you have and how thin the outlines are, the logo seems choppy and disjointed. A little simplification and stylization would go a long way here.Thanks for your clarification and opinions. Out of curiosity I checked out your logos on your redesign project and I now don't feel so bad about your criticism.To my point, I am not a fan of many logos looking similar. Examples are your excessive use of positive letter spacingas well as so many logos with city/location below the team name. Your most original, the Twins is horrendousand putting the Old English font on a curved path... are you a tattoo artist or truck painter?Looks like neither one of us have a chance to sell a logo design! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rambulance Posted September 22, 2009 Share Posted September 22, 2009 Look at other NFL logos, they generally don't have...I appreciate the C+C from you all!I'm not saying you have to copy an existing logo, but with how many elements you have and how thin the outlines are, the logo seems choppy and disjointed. A little simplification and stylization would go a long way here.Thanks for your clarification and opinions. Out of curiosity I checked out your logos on your redesign project and I now don't feel so bad about your criticism.To my point, I am not a fan of many logos looking similar. Examples are your excessive use of positive letter spacingas well as so many logos with city/location below the team name. Your most original, the Twins is horrendousand putting the Old English font on a curved path... are you a tattoo artist or truck painter?Looks like neither one of us have a chance to sell a logo design!So, you ask for C&C, some was given, and you didn't like it so you go out of your way to find something that he did so you could criticize it. Don't ask for opinions and then fight the ones given. You chose to post your concept here for the world to see, you have to expect that not all will like it.And answering his criticism with "Yeah, well your's suck too"....really? What are we in 6th grade?For the record, bohob was right on.... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bohob Posted September 22, 2009 Share Posted September 22, 2009 Look at other NFL logos, they generally don't have...I appreciate the C+C from you all!I'm not saying you have to copy an existing logo, but with how many elements you have and how thin the outlines are, the logo seems choppy and disjointed. A little simplification and stylization would go a long way here.Thanks for your clarification and opinions. Out of curiosity I checked out your logos on your redesign project and I now don't feel so bad about your criticism.To my point, I am not a fan of many logos looking similar. Examples are your excessive use of positive letter spacingas well as so many logos with city/location below the team name. Your most original, the Twins is horrendousand putting the Old English font on a curved path... are you a tattoo artist or truck painter?Looks like neither one of us have a chance to sell a logo design!So, you ask for C&C, some was given, and you didn't like it so you go out of your way to find something that he did so you could criticize it. Don't ask for opinions and then fight the ones given. You chose to post your concept here for the world to see, you have to expect that not all will like it.And answering his criticism with "Yeah, well your's suck too"....really? What are we in 6th grade?For the record, bohob was right on....Thank you. And for the record, I have sold multiple logo designs, most notably the 2009 Midwest League All-Star Game. So for you (Patchez) to say that I don't have a chance is just flat out ignorant. NHL 2016 by Bowen Hobbs * BOHOB's MLB Redesign Project * MiLB Re-Brands * NCAA Football Concepts Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Patchez Posted September 22, 2009 Author Share Posted September 22, 2009 And answering his criticism with "Yeah, well your's suck too"....really? What are we in 6th grade?Thank you. And for the record, I have sold multiple logo designs, most notably the 2009 Midwest League All-Star Game. So for you (Patchez) to say that I don't have a chance is just flat out ignorant.bohob, I was ignorant and I now sit corrected! I'd bow to you but I don't wanna get up right now. (I liked the above mentioned ML AS logo by the way!)As for your boyfriend and defender Rambulance, I did sell lemonade in 6th grade! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rambulance Posted September 22, 2009 Share Posted September 22, 2009 now THAT'S funny! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Buster Posted September 22, 2009 Share Posted September 22, 2009 you guys realize that none of this arguing about nicknames actually gives the OP the c/c he was looking for, right?Correct. That is why I stated Monuments is a horrible name for a team and the logo looks like a Roman Numeral XX. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bohob Posted September 22, 2009 Share Posted September 22, 2009 As for your boyfriend and defender Rambulance, I did sell lemonade in 6th grade!Thanks for the back-handed apology. Real civilized. NHL 2016 by Bowen Hobbs * BOHOB's MLB Redesign Project * MiLB Re-Brands * NCAA Football Concepts Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.