Jump to content

ren69

Members
  • Posts

    964
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    11

Posts posted by ren69

  1. Hola amigos soy nuevo en el foro me encanta recoger diseñador ma les logotipos de la NCAA 'y me gustaría mostrar algunas contribuciones espero que les guste yo soy de Ecuador Saludos a todos

    Bien venido al foro y muchas gracias por la contribucion, buen trabajo!

    Thanks for all the props on my BYU logo guys, appreciate it! Though it would've been cool if they used my version, I totally understand why they would go with a design firm to do their logo restoration and if they did use my version for inspiration I'm not bothered by it at all...I'm actually flattered it looks a lot like mine, lol. If people outside these boards start to compare and question the two, they would be the one's who have to explain the similarities even though they both come from the same vintage logo. In the sports logos forum under hettinger's vintage college mascot logos thread someone posted the NEW logo with my version alongside it as the OLD original logo. So at the end of the day...it's all good to me!

    EDIT: Just saw this SB NATION article on the BYU logo also using my version as the OLD & original for comparison with the NEW.

    http://www.vanquishthefoe.com/byu-cougars-basketball/2014/11/13/7214877/updated-sailor-coug-byu-secondary-logo-all-sports

    Kudos to you ren, for taking the high road on this...but I'm calling B.S. on the folks at BYU and Torch Creative.

    One of two things happened...

    1- Nobody was aware of, or saw your rendering...OR

    2-They saw it, liked it, and pretty much just tweaked your work.

    The works are too similar for me to believe the first option, so I'm saying that the latter was probably the case.

    As Delayed Penalty observed...both works are "tracings" of an existing logo, so they will be similar.

    However, even in tracings, there's a hundred different ways to render it.

    I find that the weight and style of the lines, and the treatments of certain areas are just too similar to be coincidental.

    So, what would be the big deal for them to man-up, and admit that they were influenced by your excellent work, and give you some credit for this new product.

    That would be the right thing to do.

    Thanks Sparky! I doubt they would ever admit using my version as their reference if in fact they did use it.

  2. Thanks for all the props on my BYU logo guys, appreciate it! Though it would've been cool if they used my version, I totally understand why they would go with a design firm to do their logo restoration and if they did use my version for inspiration I'm not bothered by it at all...I'm actually flattered it looks a lot like mine, lol. If people outside these boards start to compare and question the two, they would be the one's who have to explain the similarities even though they both come from the same vintage logo. In the sports logos forum under hettinger's vintage college mascot logos thread someone posted the NEW logo with my version alongside it as the OLD original logo. So at the end of the day...it's all good to me!

    EDIT: Just saw this SB NATION article on the BYU logo also using my version as the OLD & original for comparison with the NEW.

    http://www.vanquishthefoe.com/byu-cougars-basketball/2014/11/13/7214877/updated-sailor-coug-byu-secondary-logo-all-sports

    • Like 1
  3. Ren,

    Amazing work! These types of concept redesign/refresh have been in the front of my mind for the last few years. I can't believe I never explored these threads before. A little over a year ago I started ideas for a redesign of the high school I have been teaching at for the last 7 years. It was a new school and never put the proper time and effort into the logo design and branding. Most logos were very generic (from apparel vendors) or heavily inspired by trademarked professional teams. As time (and life) went on, I never had a chance to finish my redesign/re-branding concept, and since I am not experienced with Illustrator I gave up. Finding your vintage updates has INSPIRED me to get back to the task.

    I would love any help or suggestions you might have.rebrand.png

    I think you have a very solid start here, especially for someone not using Illustrator! There are several free programs available online that many members here use you might wanna try. Never give up...finish what you started here then start a concept thread on it to get input from the many members here who have a lot of valuable input to offer, you can even start it with what you have now. That will help you take this logo to the next level.

    Is the schools current logo similar to what you have here or is this a complete redesign your doing? There's a bit of a difference when it comes to updating/restoring logos & doing a complete redesign. I have another thread where I did complete redesigns of community college logos (link below). I have a couple of videos here on pgs 47 & 48 where you can see how I go about doing these vintage logo updates.

    http://boards.sportslogos.net/topic/99249-redesigning-community-college-logos/

    • Like 1
  4. Thanks for sharing your Pike concept on here hettinger.

    That Chicago Hornets logo is pretty solid as is techhornet, not sure if you noticed or not as you went through all 76 pgs but I don't tackle every request made. It all usually comes down to whether or not I have something to offer the logo requested, I've also had help along the way by other artists on here...some which are still contributing today.

  5. Thanks guys!

    Kewp80, don't really have the answers to your questions. I was provided with the images & asked to restore them. Maybe someone with better knowledge on those specific logos can answer your questions. Sorry about that!

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.