Houston Astros New Jersey

[LMU]

That is quite possibly the sloppiest execution of an idea I have ever seen on this board. Congratulations! I award you no points, and may god have mercy on your soul.

You really aren't helping him by saying this. And we've all seen Billy Madison before, so if you're going to still the quotes, please give credit where credit is due.

Wasn't claiming it as my own and felt, in fact, that since most knew where it was from and therefore didn't really need to put in citation in it. And when you put your own glowing criticism of your own design in the topic title, deal with what people say. It wasn't a personal judgement of the guy, and later on it the thread we even shared a laugh.

Ok, so just because he thinks his concept is somewhat good, and you know it's not, you think it's better for yourself and him to just make fun of the concept, rather than offer any constructive criticism?

If you don't have anything nice to say, just leave the 'Concept' forum area, please.

Generally, my criticism is constructive. One time I write something not too constructive, when in fact it did kind of fit, and you jump on my case. His feelings weren't hurt, so why don't you just ignore my comments if you don't like them. They weren't even directed at you.

Now, can the topic just get back on track?

I'll just throw in my $0.02. C&C should be based on suggestions such as color combinations, uniform striping... actual things that apply to the concept. If you make something that's just plain rushed and sloppy... well, you're walking into whatever is thrown your way.

[averyj]

If you don't take time to gently craft your concept, don't expect people to craft gentle feedback.

[Generic]

If you don't take time to gently craft your concept, don't expect people to craft gentle feedback.

Very true indeed