Jump to content

Fantasy Trade Opinions


bhambruiser

Recommended Posts

Ok In a Fantasy League with Standard Scoring (one point per reception) a roster size of 16 (starters- QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, TE, PK, DST). It is also a partial keeper- we get to keep three players each year.

Here is the trade offer:

Team A gets:

Julius Jones RB

and T.J. Houshmandezah WR

Team B gets:

Carnell Williams RB

and Joey Galloway WR

Which team comes out better in this trade?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the team getting Caddy and Galloway. it's actually a tossup for me cus Caddy's only slightly better than Julius, I think...but Galloway is a better receiver than Houshmanzadeh IMO

I sort of wish somebody had stopped me from trading LT :hockeysmiley: otherwise I wouldn't be 0-3

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the team getting Caddy and Galloway. it's actually a tossup for me cus Caddy's only slightly better than Julius, I think...but Galloway is a better receiver than Houshmanzadeh IMO

I sort of wish somebody had stopped me from trading LT :hockeysmiley: otherwise I wouldn't be 0-3

Damn Discrim, you traded LT, who did you get back for him. It does sound like a stupid trade to me, as far as your trade bham, I would either take or keep Cadillac, he will become a premeire back, and Joey is a much better receiver as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ok, thanks to everyone for the responses. I have revoked the current trade.

Here goes trade option re-worked:

Team A gets:

Carnell Williams

Team B gets:

Julius Jones, Chris Chambers and 2006 First-Round Pick

Is that enough for Carnell or too much...who comes out better in this one?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Team A gets:

Carnell Williams

Team B gets:

Julius Jones, Chris Chambers and 2006 First-Round Pick

Is that enough for Carnell or too much...who comes out better in this one?

That is too much for Caddy. I'd probably go with Jones & Chambers, or (more likely in non-keepers) Jones & the Pick.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Discrim, what should have stopped you from trading LT was the fact that the team recieving him already had Alexander, and with the new WC position, he could start both.

i had something I needed done and I'd forgotten about the Requests forum...and also forgot to look at his roster. Had I done either one, I never would have done it. Basically I traded LT for a couple vectors, some picks, and Tatum Bell.

back on topic, team B is robbin ya...I like Chambers, and I like Julius. I don't think either one is worth giving up Cadillac for individually, though...together, I still don't think so. the first rounder and a better receiver would probably do it, though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.