2011 New York-Penn League All-Star Game Logo

[bohob]

Here's the winner of the 2011 NYPL All-Star Game logo contest.

http://lowell.spinners.milb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20100528&content_id=10529706&vkey=news_t558&fext=.jsp

And here is all the entries (mine was #13):

https://secure.minorleaguebaseball.com/tickets/form.jsp?formid=logo&formcode=vote&sid=t558&section=fans

Do what you do best CCSLC. Sound off!

[BBTV]

There's nothing really "all stary" about yours - it's kind of like a logo just for the stadium. It's well done, it just doesn't reflect the type of event well IMO.

[bohob]

I'm not upset about not winning, I'm upset an amalgamation of clip art won.

[slapshot]

Mine were 9 & 10. Like bohob, I'm not upset I lost, because there were quite a few I would hove voted for.

But not the winning one. I think there are too many colors and things going on in it.

[TBGKon]

Of all of the MiLB ASG logos I have seen, I would have to say the ones that fit the mold the most are:

#10

#9

#3

[oddball]

To me, my favorites and the ones that catch my eye are #1,#5, and #6. The logos that you guys did were excellent as well, but those are the ones that catch my eye and I keep going back to.

[tajmccall]

Nicely done, gentleman. I liked your entries years before the one they chose. But such is life. The client rarely likes your best work.

[aci]

I agree with both you guys that the winner wasn't exactly deserving here. It says he's won twice in a row, and that combined with one of the worst logos makes me suspect someone was stuffing the ballot box.

[patsox]

my favorite is #10. great job on that one slapshot, it's really awesome and it should have won.

[raysox]

I like 10, 13, 15 the best. What is the object that appears in most of the concepts?

[slapshot]

The round arch shape is an architectural element of the bridge that runs alongside the field. It is also used as an archway over the main entrance to the stadium.

[mania]

4 and 15 were my favorites of the lot, easily. It's really a shame that THING won.

[mania]

I agree with both you guys that the winner wasn't exactly deserving here. It says he's won twice in a row, and that combined with one of the worst logos makes me suspect someone was stuffing the ballot box.

Doing a little bit of research... he's Kevin Smith's webmaster, so he's had that entire fanbase voting for him. That explains it.

[-kj]

#15. It's not even a race.

That said, I don't hate what they chose. It's just not in the same league as #15.

[CJworks]

#14, 15, and 9 here. I was kinda surprised when I saw the winner... obviously this wasn't a contest on best design.

[bohob]

Slapshot, you did #10? That was my favorite of the group (other than mine, of course)! Great work.

[kc51design]

1 and 15 are a class above the others, but surprisingly all are good, can't say that any one is a terrible logo.

[walkerws]

13, 15, 1! 6 isn't bad but it's too generic.

[Buster]

#1, 13, 14 and 15 are good. They chose possibly the worst one though! (along with #11)

I really like #1 and #14...yours is GREAT but as someone else said, it looks more like a well-done stadium tribute.

[slapshot]

I voted for #15 a few times, then went with my ego.