Jump to content

Jeff Garcia for comeback player of the year?


Brendan

Recommended Posts

I am not sure what the official criteria is for the "Comeback player of the year" award, but I think it has to do with overcoming injury.

Last year, Garcia played poorly for a horrible team. Now he is playing well for a good team. I don't see that as "coming back" from anything.

I think Carson Palmer will win the award. His career was in jeopardy from that knee injury and now he is a Pro Bowl player.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am not sure what the official criteria is for the "Comeback player of the year" award, but I think it has to do with overcoming injury.

Last year, Garcia played poorly for a horrible team. Now he is playing well for a good team. I don't see that as "coming back" from anything.

I think Carson Palmer will win the award. His career was in jeopardy from that knee injury and now he is a Pro Bowl player.

CPOTY has nothing to do with the player suffering an injury. Kitna won it in 2003, and other than the fact that they went from 2-14 to 8-8, he didn't improve much figuring that he only played 14 games in 2002.

My CPOTY has to be Marc Bulger.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chad Pennington is my come back player. To have that injury last season and to have the surgery he had and to progress this well is spectacular, alot and i mean ALOT of QBs dont have that surgery and do that well. Also to have 2 QBs with starting potential looking over ya shoulder cause people dont think u will make it through a whole season cause you have that reputation and to succeed. To have a team with a rookie young head coach, a bunch of players that hardly anyone outside NY knows and predicted not to win more than 4 games. Chad overcame all of this and is on the verge of taking the Jets to the playoff. NO ONE expected that. He face the most obversity and overcame every obstical that came his way.

*Chad Pennington, QB of the NY JETS, for Comback Player of the Year*

-Chad approves this message.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chad Pennington is my come back player. To have that injury last season and to have the surgery he had and to progress this well is spectacular, alot and i mean ALOT of QBs dont have that surgery and do that well. Also to have 2 QBs with starting potential looking over ya shoulder cause people dont think u will make it through a whole season cause you have that reputation and to succeed. To have a team with a rookie young head coach, a bunch of players that hardly anyone outside NY knows and predicted not to win more than 4 games. Chad overcame all of this and is on the verge of taking the Jets to the playoff. NO ONE expected that. He face the most obversity and overcame every obstical that came his way.

*Chad Pennington, QB of the NY JETS, for Comback Player of the Year*

-Chad approves this message.

We have a winner.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have to go with Drew Brees. His shoulder scared off a lot of teams, even when the doctor who operated on it told these teams he couldn't have done a better job on it. A torn labrum and a partially torn rotator cuff in the final week of last season, and the next season he's an MVP candidate. He has to be the comeback player of the year. Jeff Garcia is nice but he's done it for five starts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chad Pennington is my come back player. To have that injury last season and to have the surgery he had and to progress this well is spectacular, alot and i mean ALOT of QBs dont have that surgery and do that well. Also to have 2 QBs with starting potential looking over ya shoulder cause people dont think u will make it through a whole season cause you have that reputation and to succeed. To have a team with a rookie young head coach, a bunch of players that hardly anyone outside NY knows and predicted not to win more than 4 games. Chad overcame all of this and is on the verge of taking the Jets to the playoff. NO ONE expected that. He face the most obversity and overcame every obstical that came his way.

*Chad Pennington, QB of the NY JETS, for Comback Player of the Year*

-Chad approves this message.

Chad deserves the award as much as Rex Grossman does.

If the comeback player of the year isn't Bulger, it'll be Javon Walker.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Pennington or Garcia deserve it the most.

Palmer and Brees I don't feel apply(Even though I know everyone is gonna disagree with me) because they were good at the end of last year and and good at the beginning of this year so the didn't really come back from anything on the field.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Right now it looks like Garcia is just what the Eagles need......comeback player ...no .....but he has done one heck of a job .... :D

It's amazing how everyone looks like a world beater once they fill in for Donovan's annual season-ending injury. AJ Feeley? Koy Detmer?

Mike McMahon?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.